Console Login

OpenVZ vs. KVM in 2012: Why Your "Guaranteed" RAM Might Be a Lie

OpenVZ Containers: The Hidden Cost of "Cheap" Virtualization

It is 2012, and the hosting market is flooded with offers for $5 VPS plans boasting "unlimited" potential. As a systems architect managing infrastructure across the Nordics, I see the fallout of these marketing promises every week. Clients migrate their Magento stores or high-traffic Joomla sites to these budget nodes, only to watch them crumble under load.

The culprit is often not the hardware, but the virtualization technology itself. While OpenVZ has democratized access to hosting, it comes with architectural trade-offs that serious administrators must understand. If you care about consistent latency and true resource isolation for your Norwegian user base, you need to look under the hood.

The Architecture: Shared Kernel vs. True Isolation

OpenVZ is operating-system-level virtualization. It relies on a shared Linux kernel. When you SSH into your CentOS 6 container, you aren't running your own kernel; you are running a chrooted userspace on top of the host's kernel.

This approach is brilliant for density. A host can pack hundreds of containers onto a single physical server because there is almost no overhead. But for you, the user, it introduces the "Noisy Neighbor" problem. If another customer on the same physical node decides to compile a massive C++ project or gets hit by a DDoS attack, your I/O and CPU scheduling suffer immediately.

The Dreaded user_beancounters

On a KVM or Xen VPS (like the ones we provision at CoolVDS), if you run out of RAM, Linux swaps or invokes the OOM (Out of Memory) killer on a specific process. On OpenVZ, memory management is dictated by User Beancounters (UBC).

I have lost count of the number of times a developer has asked me, "Why is Java crashing? `free -m` says I have 512MB left!" The answer lies in /proc/user_beancounters. OpenVZ limits not just physical RAM, but kernel memory allocations, number of files, and socket buffers.

Here is what you need to check immediately if your services are dying silently:

[root@server ~]# cat /proc/user_beancounters 
Version: 2.5
       uid       resource           held    maxheld    barrier      limit    failcnt
      101:  kmemsize            2882344    3142233   14336000   14790656          0
            lockedpages               0          0        256        256          0
            privvmpages           68212      72456      69632      69632      1402
            physpages             21124      24211          0 2147483647          0
            numproc                  22         35        240        240          0
            tcpsndbuf            242220     422112    3194880    5242880          0
            tcprcvbuf            211244     522111    3194880    5242880          0

Look at the failcnt (fail count) column. In the example above, privvmpages has a fail count of 1402. This means the application requested memory 1,402 times and was denied by the hypervisor, even if the operating system tools like top or free showed memory available. This discrepancy is the number one cause of instability in OpenVZ environments.

Performance: The I/O Bottleneck

In 2012, storage is the biggest bottleneck. While we are seeing the emergence of enterprise SSDs and early PCIe storage solutions, most budget VPS providers still run on SATA 7.2k RPM drives in RAID arrays. In an OpenVZ environment, the I/O barrier is shared. There is no strict reservation.

If you are running a database like MySQL 5.5, you need guaranteed IOPS. On OpenVZ, your innodb_flush_log_at_trx_commit setting might cause significant wait times if a neighbor is heavy on disk writes.

Optimization Tip: If you are stuck on OpenVZ, you must reduce your memory footprint. For MySQL, ensure your InnoDB buffer pool is set conservatively to avoid hitting the privvmpages barrier:

# /etc/my.cnf
[mysqld]
# On a 1GB OpenVZ VPS, do not set this above 384M
innodb_buffer_pool_size = 384M
query_cache_limit = 1M
query_cache_size = 16M

The Security and Compliance Angle in Norway

For our clients here in Norway, reliance on shared kernels poses a theoretical security risk. A kernel exploit (like the recent CVEs affecting Linux 2.6.32) can potentially allow an attacker to escape a container. While patches are released quickly, the shared nature means you are dependent on your host's patching schedule.

Furthermore, complying with the Personopplysningsloven (Personal Data Act) and ensuring data integrity often requires a level of isolation that containers struggle to prove. When the Datatilsynet (Data Protection Authority) asks where your data lives and who can access it, "shared kernel memory" is a difficult conversation.

Pro Tip: Use top and look at the st (steal time) value. If this number is consistently above 5-10%, your host is overselling CPU cycles. Move your workload immediately.

The CoolVDS Approach: Why We Use KVM

At CoolVDS, we have made a strategic decision to prioritize performance and isolation over density. This is why our primary platform is built on KVM (Kernel-based Virtual Machine).

With KVM, you get:

  • A Dedicated Kernel: Load custom modules (like TUN/TAP for VPNs) without asking support.
  • True RAM Reservation: No failcnt. If you buy 2GB, you get 2GB physical RAM.
  • Block Device Isolation: We use high-performance RAID-10 SSD arrays, and we are currently testing next-gen PCIe storage technology to further reduce latency.

While OpenVZ has its place—primarily for development environments, simple VPN endpoints, or static web serving—it is not suitable for the mission-critical workloads required by modern businesses in Oslo and beyond.

Conclusion

Don't let a budget virtualization technology compromise your uptime. If your failcnt is rising or your steal time is high, it is time to migrate.

We offer VPS Norway solutions hosted directly in Oslo to ensure minimal latency for your local users. Experience the difference of dedicated resources and premium connectivity.

Ready to stop fighting for resources? Deploy a high-performance KVM instance with SSD storage on CoolVDS today.